Really apologized for the late reply as I saw your reply today.
My system is monolayer alpha In2Se3 which has predominant out of plane polarization.
Actually I calculated Polarization based on Berry phase calculation provided in abinit website in the link[
https://docs.abinit.org/topics/Berry/].
The output file pops out with no errors
Polarization in cartesian coordinates (C/m^2):
(the sum of the electronic and ionic Berry phase has been folded into [-1, 1])
Electronic berry phase: -0.363359383E-04 -0.209785676E-04 0.409497792E+00
Ionic: 0.755329491E-01 0.436089685E-01 -0.415614991E+00
Total: 0.754966131E-01 0.435879899E-01 -0.611719867E-02
I don't have much understanding about the result.
My understanding says
polarization (pol) along x = 0.075 C/m^2
polarization (pol) along y = 0.045 C/m^2
polarization (pol) along z= -0.00611 C/m^2
Literature says those material has predominant Out of plane polarization.
In my setup out of plane is along z axis and vacuum is along z axis too.
As pol along x involves quantum of polarization so it should be less than 0.075 and same holds for y.
My question is
1. Does pol along z which is -0.00611 involves quantum of polarization?
I believe it shouldn't as out of plane polarization involves vacuum.
Also whenever literature reports out of plane polarization are they using Berry phase method or something else.
2. Does Berry phase method only apply for in plane polarization?
I am confused so any of your help would be really appreciable.
Thank you