Hello ABINIT forums,
I am currently working on the structural optimization of the double perovskite Cs2AgBiCl6 under 15 GPa of pressure. I have already read many posts of this general topic on the forum and from other sources. This is what I've managed to come up within my input file. The problem I am encountering is as follows:
Choice of acell, ngfft, and ecut
===> basis sphere extends BEYOND fft box !
Recall that boxcut=Gcut(box)/Gcut(sphere) must be > 1.
Action : try larger ngfft or smaller ecut.
Note that ecut=effcut/boxcut**2 and effcut= 37.823589
What can I change to resolve this issue?
Thanks!
Cs2AgBiCl6 structural optimizati under pressure boxcut error
Moderator: bguster
Cs2AgBiCl6 structural optimizati under pressure boxcut error
- Attachments
-
Cs2AgBiCl6_acell.in- (911 Bytes) Downloaded 265 times
-
- Cs2AgBiCl6_acell.out
- (61.4 KiB) Downloaded 247 times
Re: Cs2AgBiCl6 structural optimizati under pressure boxcut e
Dear erichyang,
Looking at your input, you are doing a cell relaxation but you did not define dilatmx flag, the default value is 1.0, which should be changed to 1.02-1.05 or so, I think this could make you boxcut problem.
Otherwise, a small advice, since you have internal atomic relaxations too, you better use toldff flag to stop the SCF instead of toldfe, a good advise is to use toldff=tolmxf/10.
Best wishes,
Eric
Looking at your input, you are doing a cell relaxation but you did not define dilatmx flag, the default value is 1.0, which should be changed to 1.02-1.05 or so, I think this could make you boxcut problem.
Otherwise, a small advice, since you have internal atomic relaxations too, you better use toldff flag to stop the SCF instead of toldfe, a good advise is to use toldff=tolmxf/10.
Best wishes,
Eric
-
hameed1987
- Posts: 41
- Joined: Sat Jun 22, 2019 12:45 pm
- Location: The UK
Re: Cs2AgBiCl6 structural optimizati under pressure boxcut e
Dear Eric
Your answer is also useful to me as well because of optimization, but Ii did not understand the value of toldff=tolmxf/10. please tell me that These both should be 10?
Hameed
Your answer is also useful to me as well because of optimization, but Ii did not understand the value of toldff=tolmxf/10. please tell me that These both should be 10?
Hameed
Dear All,
WR
Hameed
WR
Hameed
Re: Cs2AgBiCl6 structural optimizati under pressure boxcut e
Dear Hameed,
I meant toldff should be at least 10 times smaller than tolmxf. Toldff is a flag to stop the SCF electronic cycle by taking the residual on the forces to stop it and not on energy or so. Since you are relaxing your structure it is better to stop the SCF on the forces rather than on the energy since the important quantity here is the forces and not the energy.
Best wishes,
Eric
I meant toldff should be at least 10 times smaller than tolmxf. Toldff is a flag to stop the SCF electronic cycle by taking the residual on the forces to stop it and not on energy or so. Since you are relaxing your structure it is better to stop the SCF on the forces rather than on the energy since the important quantity here is the forces and not the energy.
Best wishes,
Eric